| Year |
Result |
MVP |
| 2002 |
Tulane 36, Hawai‘i 28 |
Lyraris Elpheage, Tulane Justin Colbert, Hawai‘i |
| 2003 |
Hawai‘i 54, Houston 48 (3OT) |
Timmy Chang, Hawai‘i Jackie Battle, Houston |
| 2004 |
Hawai‘i 59, UAB 40 |
Timmy Chang, Hawai‘i Chad Owens, Hawai‘i Darrell Hackney, UAB |
| 2005 |
Nevada 49, Central Florida 48 (OT) |
B.J. Mitchell, Nevada Brandon Marshall, Central Florida |
| 2006 |
Hawai‘i 41, Arizona State 24 |
Colt Brennan, Hawai‘i Jason Rivers, Hawai‘i Ryan Torain, Arizona State |
| 2007 |
East Carolina 41, Boise State 38 |
Chris Johnson, East Carolina Jeremy Avery, Boise State |
| 2008 |
Notre Dame 49, Hawai‘i 21 |
Jimmy Clausen, Notre Dame Golden Tate, Notre Dame Aaron Bain, Hawai‘i |
| 2009 |
SMU 45, Nevada 10 |
Kyle Padron, SMU Kevin Basped, Nevada |
| 2010 |
Tulsa 62, Hawai‘i 35 |
Damaris Johnson, Tulsa Greg Salas, Hawai‘i |
| 2011 |
Southern Miss 24, Nevada 17 |
Cordarro Law, Southern Miss Lampford Mark, Nevada |
|